
Court actor · Public record · Alabama
William E.Scully, Jr.
Judge
25 families reportedBaldwinLatest report Aug 2026
Sponsored by
SHARE THE SLIDES
The exact pack Meg posts — cover, every family quote, state stats, the global pattern, and the closing cards. Straight from the live generator.
Loading slides…
WHAT FAMILIES SAY
Scully kept prolonging the court dates. Wouldn't listen to anyone but the dhr attorney
The judge and the opposing attorney were overheard just before court. The opposing attorney told the judge how much he had donated to "the cause". The judge thanked him very much. During the trial, the Judge indicated that the opposing side should ask for more money and used depreciation income from my company to justify alimony above what was even requested. At one point the alimony and taxes demand by the judge was more than I even made.
See previous comments. The judge denied Dr. Jack C. Carney, Ph.D.'s request for an emergency change in custody.
Deleting documents from the record. Will not allow me to speak. Sides with dhr
My child’s father and I had 50/50 custody and I wanted to continue it. He said I wasnt stable due to me moving from home to home (rentals) never owned a home. I was was representing myself Pro Se and asked for a continuation of the case in which was denied. I had to fight for myself without a representation, had no idea what to do on the stand.. they painted me as a non stable person and I’m a good mom. Judge Scully took my 50/50 away and gave dad full custody with primary decision making while I have only have visitation
Ignored evidence and took sides with who liked that day
Ignored evidence ; wouldn’t let me speak was very rude
Trying to give dad visitation when he's done drugs around his kid , is a felon , has multiple i mean MULTIPLE DV cases against him.
Ignored evidence, rubber stamped father’s motions while denying all of mother’s without justification or hearing. Ordered invasive discovery without cause or required safeguards. Threatened to fine mother instead of protecting children. Failed to timely schedule hearings.
Did not listen to my testimony. Lied and said my daughter had left rehab. She was still there.
Another judge that doesn’t want listen to evidence just wants to listen to what DHR says no matter that they don’t have proof. All just “feelings” and what they think a person might do.
He wouldn't except none of my drug test i paid for and it was like he had his mind up already he didn't care to listen to what i had and everyone was so against me and I have never abused my kids or anything it didn't make sense
Dismissed a long-standing protective order without reviewing documentary evidence I had submitted or requested to present.
He keeps children away without hearings.
ONLY LISTENING TO DHR NOT LETTIN ME SPEAK NOR WAS DHR LETTIN ME TALK
They didnt even let me testify
The custody case remained stayed for an extended period while related criminal proceedings were pending. During a related hearing, evidence was presented but the court indicated the issues should be addressed through family court proceedings.
I had to get on the ladder and he will take her side punish me get onto me without listening to any facts and and believe her lies in her attorneys, fabricated instances
All of the listed issues plus more, Continued supervised visitation based on stated “mental health concerns” without identifying any diagnosis, specific mental-health condition, or evidence showing that my mental health creates a danger to Henry. This is despite the court-ordered psychological evaluation showing valid testing within normal clinical limits, no significant psychopathology, and describing me as an involved parent with exceptional parenting skills. Dr. Arata’s report identified substantially more concrete concerns regarding Dewitt, including parenting availability, minimization potentially indicating disengagement/neglect, narcissistic traits, and a history of interpersonal violence.
He took away my children with no evidence hearing
Has never been given an evidentiary hearing.
Didn’t care to hear me plead my case believed everything he was told knowing it was lies n defamation of character
Drags out court cases also believes false reports
He has been my judge for my 6 previous accusations of abuse by my coparent in attempts to modify custody. He has always awarded me primary physical custody of my children. He has always upheld the law but did sway towards DHR recommendations.
Violated my civil rights and never considered the best interest of my daughter
Dismissed my case without proper procedures and violated my civil rights
Dismissed case without following proper procedures and violated my civil rights
Repeatedly ignored evidence, engages in ex parte comms, ignores domestic violence, blames victims, denies notice and due process
These are allegations reported directly by families through the survey. They are published because 25 unrelated households independently described this court actor — the public-record threshold.
Family-reported submissions.